What happened to Google Maps?
Sunday, December 27, 2009 at 6:16PM Since Google Maps was released in 2005, it has become the gold standard of Web-based mapping applications. For many people, including myself, Google isn't just the best choice... it's the only choice. Even as Google Maps has evolved and become more robust and useful, I think it may be tumbling from its dominant position.
Here's a Google Maps view of an area near the center of my town. Looks fine, right? But here's the problem: Most of the streets in this screenshot don't exist. Here's the same area in satellite view:
As the satellite image shows, where Google Maps says there are streets, there's actually just a whole bunch of nothing.
What's strange about this is that until recently, Google Maps was very accurate. Since I don't have a navigation system, I've relied on Google Maps for directions for years, and I've been able to do so without having to double check for accuracy. But in the past three months, since Google has allowed people to report a problem with their maps, I've done so over 30 times. Among the errors I've reported:
- Liberty Island (home of the Statue of Liberty) and Ellis Island mislabeled as each other, despite the mislabeled "Ellis Island" having the correctly labeled Statue of Liberty on it.
- The Rutgers-Newark campus mislabeled as the New Brunswick campus, despite being in downtown Newark right next to the word Newark in big, bold letters.
- Newark Liberty International Airport misnamed and shown as being in the middle of downtown Newark.
- Rutgers' Busch Campus mislabeled as UMDNJ.
- Jackson, NJ shown as being in Camden County, about 50 miles away from its correct location in Ocean County.
At this point, I've come across so many errors that I might as well just give up and start using Bing. Unlike Google, Bing gets it right:
Even the much-maligned Mapquest and hey-wait-they're-still-around? Yahoo Maps are accurate.
![]()
It's as if Google got their data from a guy on the street who thinks he remembers the location of that place you're looking for and gives you rambling, vague directions on how to get there. When Mapquest trumps Google on one of its core products, something has gone horribly wrong.
Bing,
Google,
Google Maps,
Yahoo 